My Doctor Won't Prescribe MHT: What Are Your Options?
PLAY THE EPISODE
26 min · Listen on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube
Show Notes
You finally asked about hormones, and the answer came back before you'd finished the sentence. This episode is about working out whether that was medicine or a reflex.
Dr. Siân West, board-certified OB-GYN and menopause specialist, explains how the 2002 Women's Health Initiative headlines still shape exam rooms. Then she reads the labeled contraindication list for hormone therapy out loud and points to what isn't on it, including a family history of breast cancer and your age.
She covers where the migraine with aura warning actually comes from, why plenty of clinicians who'll prescribe estrogen won't prescribe testosterone, and why compounded pellets carry less oversight than people assume. You'll leave with four questions for your next appointment and a way to find a menopause-trained clinician if you need a different room.
What you'll learn
What the WHI actually found in 2002, and what the estrogen-alone arm found
The labeled contraindication list, read out loud, and what is not on it
Where the migraine with aura restriction actually comes from
Why clinicians who write for estrogen often will not write for testosterone
Why a normal testosterone level is a monitoring result, not a gate
Why compounded testosterone pellets carry less oversight, not more
A clinician saying no quickly and the evidence saying no sound identical from where you're sitting. You're allowed to find out which one you got.
Questions this episode answers
Why won't my doctor prescribe MHT?
Some refusals reflect a genuine contraindication in your history. Many reflect training that stopped updating after the 2002 Women's Health Initiative headlines, when prescriptions collapsed and a generation of clinicians learned to avoid hormone therapy broadly. A real contraindication has a name and a reason and can be said in one sentence. If you ask what specifically about your history makes this unsafe and the answer is a general remark about hormones, you were given a reflex rather than an assessment.
What are the actual contraindications to hormone therapy?
The labeled contraindications for estrogen therapy or estrogen-progestogen therapy are: undiagnosed abnormal genital bleeding; known, suspected or a history of breast cancer, except in appropriately selected patients with oncology involvement; a known or suspected estrogen-dependent cancer; active or previous deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism; active or recent arterial thromboembolic disease such as stroke or heart attack within the past year; liver dysfunction or disease; known or suspected pregnancy; known hypersensitivity to the therapy; and porphyria cutanea tarda. That list is the same whether the product is systemic or local.
Is a family history of breast cancer a contraindication to MHT?
No. Family history does not appear on the labeled contraindication list for hormone therapy. What appears there is a personal history of breast cancer. A relative's diagnosis is something a clinician should factor into an individual conversation about your own risk, but it is not a contraindication to hormone therapy and a flat refusal on that basis is not supported by the labeling.
Does MHT cause breast cancer?
The 2002 Women's Health Initiative reported increased breast cancer risk with one specific combined hormone therapy, conjugated equine estrogen plus the synthetic progestin MPA. In absolute terms the increase was eight additional cases of invasive breast cancer per ten thousand women per year. In the other arm of the same trial, women who had a hysterectomy and took estrogen alone had lower breast cancer risk than placebo. Risk depends on hormone type, dose, delivery route, personal history and timing.
Why won't my doctor prescribe testosterone?
There is no testosterone product approved by the FDA for women in the United States. The transdermal gels available are approved for men and are used off-label for women in reduced amounts, with monitoring of levels to avoid supraphysiologic dosing. Off-label prescribing is legal and routine, but it involves more monitoring and more clinical responsibility than prescribing a product labeled for the indication, and some clinicians decline for that reason rather than because the therapy lacks evidence.
What should I ask if my doctor says no to hormone therapy?
Open the appointment with: "I would like to talk through what is going on and what my options are, including MHT." If the answer is a fast no, follow with: "What specifically about my history makes this unsafe for me?" If that answer is vague, ask: "Is there a route or a formulation that would change that answer?" And if someone proposes changing a plan that is already working, ask what problem the change is solving. A real contraindication can be named in one sentence.
Is a clotting disorder a reason not to take MHT?
An active or previous deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism is a labeled contraindication to hormone therapy. A thrombophilia on its own, with no clot ever, does not appear on that list. Where a previous clot was provoked by a clear one-off cause, transdermal estrogen may be reasonable to consider, because patches and gels have not been shown to carry the clot risk that oral estrogen does. That is an individualized decision rather than an automatic no.
Is an estrogen patch safer than a pill?
For blood clot risk, delivery route matters. Transdermal estrogen, meaning patches and gels, has not been shown to increase venous thromboembolism risk, while oral estrogen carries a small increase. This is one reason the same hormone can carry a different risk profile depending on how it is delivered, and it is worth raising if clot risk was the stated reason for a refusal.
Do I need progesterone with estrogen?
If you still have your uterus, systemic estrogen is paired with progesterone or a progestogen to protect the uterine lining. Estrogen alone stimulates the lining, and without a progestogen to oppose it that raises the risk of uterine cancer. The pairing is built into the therapy rather than optional.
Can I take hormone therapy if I get migraine with aura?
The restriction most women are given comes from the contraception literature. The CDC and the World Health Organization recommend that women with migraine with aura not use combined hormonal contraception, because of a small increased risk of ischemic stroke, a risk confounded by smoking, blood pressure, diabetes and estrogen dose. The clinician's guide from The Menopause Society (formerly NAMS) states that a similar contraindication has not been identified for women with migraine who need hormone therapy doses for menopause symptoms, and notes that the adverse events seen in migraine with aura appear related primarily to the high estrogen doses used in older oral contraceptives. Menopausal doses are lower than contraceptive doses.
Am I too old for hormone therapy?
Age does not appear on the labeled contraindication list. The evidence tracks how far you are from menopause more closely than which birthday you have reached, and in a healthy woman without other risk factors the picture in her sixties looks different from what a hard age cutoff implies. It is reasonable to ask a clinician to explain the reasoning behind a stop-at-a-certain-age rule.
Is vaginal estrogen the same as hormone therapy?
Low-dose vaginal estrogen is a separate conversation from systemic MHT. Because so little of it reaches the rest of the body, most systemic cautions do not apply in practice. It is considered safe for most women, including most gynecologic cancer survivors, with their oncology team involved. The one genuine exception is a history of an estrogen-sensitive uterine sarcoma.
Should I be on the birth control pill instead of MHT?
Combined oral contraceptives are a legitimate option in perimenopause, particularly where contraception is still needed or where bleeding needs controlling. Where contraception is not needed, that advantage does not apply. Menopause guidance describes movement from hormonal contraception onto menopausal hormone therapy as a woman reaches menopause, specifically because that moves her onto lower-dose formulations, and it does not describe moving in the opposite direction. If a clinician proposes switching you from MHT to a contraceptive pill, it is reasonable to ask what problem the change is intended to solve.
Does testosterone work for women?
The clinician's guide from The Menopause Society (formerly NAMS) states that existing data are consistent in demonstrating that testosterone therapy improves multiple aspects of sexual functioning in naturally and surgically menopausal women, with or without concurrent estrogen therapy. There is evidence for efficacy in hypoactive sexual desire disorder in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women. The most common short-term adverse events are acne and unwanted hair growth. Long-term cardiovascular and breast cancer data are limited to observational studies.
My testosterone level is normal, so should I be refused treatment?
Androgen levels are not useful for diagnosing sexual dysfunction in women, so a normal testosterone result is not in itself a reason to decline treatment. Testosterone levels are recommended when testosterone therapy is being considered, but their role is monitoring once treatment is underway rather than acting as a threshold a woman has to cross before starting.
Are compounded testosterone pellets a good option?
Compounded testosterone products, including pellets, creams and ointments prepared by compounding pharmacies, are not FDA regulated. Menopause guidance describes their use as not ideal, citing concerns about quality, purity, potency and consistency, with significant variability between formulations and between batches of the same formulation. A compounded pellet carries less regulatory oversight than an FDA-approved gel prescribed off-label, not more.
Are there non-hormonal options for menopause symptoms?
Yes. If systemic hormone therapy is not right for you, whether because of your history or your own preference, non-hormonal prescription options exist. A good clinician should walk you through them with the same seriousness rather than presenting them as a consolation prize.
How do I find a menopause specialist?
Menopause-trained clinicians are more findable than most people expect, through certification directories and menopause clinics. One clinician's no is one clinician's answer rather than medicine's final word.
Resources and research mentioned
Menopause Practice: A Clinician's Guide, 6th Edition, The North American Menopause Society
Rossouw et al., 2002, JAMA, Women's Health Initiative estrogen plus progestin trial: doi.org/10.1001/jama.288.3.321
Chlebowski et al., 2010, JAMA, WHI breast cancer follow-up
Vinogradova, Coupland and Hippisley-Cox, 2019, BMJ, hormone therapy route and blood clot risk: doi.org/10.1136/bmj.k4810
Find a menopause-trained clinician: The Menopause Society practitioner directory
Related episodes
Episode 3: Why Men Get Viagra and Women Get Therapy Referrals
Episode 2: Feral, Not a Gentle Decline: The Hormone Truth About Perimenopause
About Dr. Siân West
Dr. Siân West is a board-certified OB-GYN and menopause specialist. She hosts This Meno Life, a weekly podcast for women in midlife that covers perimenopause, menopause and MHT with the evidence first and no fear tactics.
Follow This Meno Life on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube so the next episode finds you.
I'm a doctor, but not your doctor. Everything here is for education, not medical advice. Stay curious, stay evidence-based, and always talk to your clinician before making changes.
